Beauty Redefined Blog

So Much for Your “Body Peace Treaty,” Huh Seventeen?



If you needed any more ammunition to fuel your boycott of Seventeen magazine and your fight for media literacy for all, let this month’s cover be the final blow.

The magazine features “Pretty Little Liars” actress Troian Bellisario, whose cover story highlights her struggle with and recovery from an eating disorder that she believes resulted from her ideals of “perfection.” Then check out the next insightful cover story, advertised just centimeters away:

Seventeen Troian Bellesario Eating Disorder Beauty Redefined

Thanks to bR supporter Nicole, who sent us the tip on this asinine cover!

We hope the careless and harmful combination of these two messages is painfully clear, but in case it isn’t, here’s a research perspective on the problem: 

As representations of women’s bodies across all media have focused so intensely on thinness over the last 30 years, rates of eating disorders have skyrocketed – tripling for college-age women from the late 1980s to 1993 and rising since then to at least 4% of U.S. women suffering with bulimia. Approx. 10 million women are diagnosable as anorexic or bulimic, with at least 25 million more struggling with a binge eating disorder (NEDA, 2010). Perhaps more alarming is the 119% increase from 1999-2006 in the number of children under 12 hospitalized due to an eating disorder, the vast majority of whom were girls (Rosen, 2010). Though the Dept. of Health reports no exact cause of eating disorders, they state some characteristics have been linked to their development, such as low self-esteem, fear of becoming fat, and being in an environment where weight and thinness are emphasized (Rosen, 2010) – all of which are shown to be related to media exposure of idealized bodies, which is all but inescapable. 

Teaching girls how to get an “insane body” is exactly what these scholars meant by “an environment where weight and thinness are emphasized.” By highlighting a serious health problem plaguing females while simultaneously promoting the body ideals that drive many girls and women toward such extremes, Seventeen is effectively tightening the grip that eating disorders have on the girls and women within the magazine’s reach. 

This cover story fiasco comes just two short years after the magazine debuted its “Body Peace Treaty” as a response to body image activists worldwide asking Seventeen Magazine to Keep it Real by quitting the excessive Photoshopping it (and every other magazine) is guilty of. Every news outlet on the planet jumped on this story of supposedly successful petitioning that even prompted a statement from Seventeen editor Ann Shoket. Rather than summarize the amazingness (sarcasm. so much sarcasm.) of her words that were published in the July 2012 issue, we’ll let you read for yourself here:

At the time, we did a bunch of local news interviews and offered this as our official statement on the matter:

“Though we’re admittedly a little weirded out that she claims Seventeen has never been guilty of altering a girl/woman’s face or body in the magazine (which is grade-A baloney), we’re pumped that she and the magazine are taking a more public stance on their renewed commitment to showing us reality — which we believe is MUCH more beautiful anyway. BUT there’s another more serious part of this statement that we need to hold Seventeen accountable for. She says, ‘We want every girl to stop obsessing about what her body looks like and start appreciating it for what it can do!’ And we fully agree. But now it’s time for them to back up that claim. 

Seventeen, while you’re foregoing extreme Photoshopping, how about you show us some covers and articles that don’t obsess about what our bodies look like and appreciate them for what they can do!’  ‘Get your Best Bikini Body,’ ‘Look Amazing,’ and ‘Look Pretty for Summer’ (actual 2012 headlines) just aren’t cutting it. We are capable of SO much more than being looked at. It would be great if hugely  popular media outlets like Seventeen would help us believe it by showing girls as more than parts to be looked at and “fixed” — rather than just telling us to believe it in an editor’s letter. Whether or not they walk the walk instead of just talking the talk, you can start that positive body image journey for yourself with these stategies.”

So, surprise! They haven’t lived up to their end of the “Body Peace Treaty” or our challenge. Why? Because the body ideals in their pages sell everything — subscriptions, copies on the newsstand, the products advertised inside, and the dreams of every girl who just wants to look hot enough to be happy, healthy, and desirable. Petitions or not, “Body Peace Treaty” or not, why would they stop promoting unattainable ideals that will drive profits as long as girls still seek those ideals? 

More than just bodies magazine image

We’re not trying to change Seventeen or any other media. That’s a futile hope (you saw how much good 250k signatures on a petition delivered to their front door did). We’re focused on changing people’s perceptions of media and their perceptions of their own bodies. If you’re thinking, “Well, if you don’t like, it, just don’t buy it!” then you’re not alone in thinking the ostrich-style approach is easiest, but you also don’t quite grasp the influence of these publications. Seventeen sells 20 million copies every year — mostly to girls much younger than 17. This magazine sells twice as many copies as its leading competitor, is circulated worldwide, and can be seen by anyone of any age at every magazine checkout stand everywhere. Of course the first step is to cancel your subscription and boycott the magazine altogether (and we highly recommend a media fast to cleanse your mind), but we also need to have a serious conversation with our daughters, friends, students, colleagues, other parents, business owners displaying these titles, and so many others who can use their knowledge of the harms done by media to make more informed choices for themselves and those over whom they have influence.

Use your understanding of media literacy to speak up about why magazines like this one focus so much on female appearance ideals, even as they shed light on eating disorders and other health problems related to appearance ideals. Who benefits? Who suffers? Talk to anyone and everyone who will listen. You can even slap a Beauty Redefined sticky note on the covers of these magazines when they’re on display in public places! It’s a nice little reminder for anyone who happens to be browsing! One of our favorite new sticky note slogans is “See more. Be more.” When we stop believing messages sold by magazines like Seventeen that girls and women are bodies first and foremost, then we can SEE more than just bodies. Once we can see more, we can BE more! It’s up to us to change, not media. See more. Be more. THAT is Beauty Redefined.

For more steps to take back beauty for yourself, see this page of resources.


  1. Ashley

    Awesome post! We should send this post to Ann.

  2. Michelle

    “Seventeen, while you’re foregoing extreme Photoshopping, how about you show us some covers and articles that don’t “obsess about what our bodies look like and appreciate them for what they can do!” ”Get your Best Bikini Body,” “Look Amazing,” “Look Pretty,” and ”Look Pretty for Summer” just aren’t cutting it.”

    AMEN! Let’s see it, Seventeen!

  3. Gerry Dorrian
    Gerry Dorrian07-08-2012

    Personally, I can only see a limited range of skin-tones and body-shapes on the covers you post. I think Seventeen is full of, as you say, baloney.

  4. Melanie

    I agree 100% with this! I also want to pose another question in regards to the photoshop ban: How about all the advertisements in Seventeen and other publications? These are still going to be a part of the magazine, so what’s the big deal if a small percentage of the magazine avoids photoshopping?

  5. Kimberly Murriel
    Kimberly Murriel10-10-2012

    While I love seventeen heir magazine, i still don’t think they do a good job at showing, promoting, and accepting all girls. While they may have a few pages with “big” girls or girls that are bove a six 4, the overwhelming majority of the pages in their imagazine are still filled with thin white girls. I hardly ever see any black women or women of other races on the cover of their magazine.

  6. spice

    And we can’t forget our boys! I have three boys and I see it as a major job of mothering to raise my boys to respect women not for what they look like but to respect them…just because they are human beings! To refute the lies they see in the media about their ‘sisters’ and to be in solidarity in standing up against the ugly lies we are told about what it is to be Female.

    Raise our boys to use their critical thinking skills!

  7. Kat

    I notice these kinds of direct contradictions in magazines all the time.

    Most often, in women’s fitness magazines (what I spend most of my time critiquing), somewhere there is a sentence saying something like “don’t be afraid of the heavy weights!”, but then every picture of a fitness model in the magazine holds nothing bigger than a 6 pound weight. Weight recommendations for their workouts typically say 3-9 pounds.

    As well, many of the workouts are assortments of bodyweight exercises (not that there’s anything wrong with that) or exercises where the recommendation is high reps, low weight.

    It is one thing to SAY the right things. However, it must be SHOWN as well.

  8. cristele

    Am I the only one to notice that seventeen BEFORE picture (unaltered) shows a girl with a missing limb?!? This photo has *already* been altered! They are showing how they photoshop more an already phtoshopped picture.

  9. yo


Leave a Reply